Sublease vs. Assignment: Which Is Better for Your Exit Strategy?
Assignment may or may not release you from the lease, so check whether the lease or the landlord's written consent includes an express release. Subleasing keeps you in the middle — forever.
Sublease
You sublease your $5,000/month space to a subtenant at $4,500/month
- ✓ Easier to arrange — you find the tenant, landlord approves
- ✓ You continue as the responsible party — landlord relationship stays the same
- ✓ Retains lease position if you might want the space back
- ✗ You remain fully liable for master lease obligations
- ✗ Subtenant default is your problem — you pay the landlord
- ✗ You're paying $500/month (difference between master and sublease rates)
- ✗ Ongoing monitoring required — subtenant violations affect you
Assignment
You assign your $5,000/month lease to a new tenant who takes over fully
- ✓ An assignment transfers the lease to the assignee, but the original tenant may stay secondarily liable unless the landlord grants an express release.
- If the landlord expressly releases you, you may have little ongoing involvement; without a release, you may remain liable.
- ✓ Personal guaranty can be released if negotiated
- ✗ Requires landlord consent — landlord can reject or negotiate new terms
- ✗ Original guaranty may survive without explicit release
- ✗ Assignee must meet landlord's financial requirements
The Verdict: Assignment
Assignment can offer a cleaner exit than a sublease, but whether the original tenant is released depends on the lease terms and the landlord's written consent. The key is negotiating a guaranty release as a condition of assignment closing. Sublease keeps you in the middle indefinitely, creates double liability exposure, and requires ongoing monitoring. Use sublease only when assignment isn't available.
Key Factors in This Decision
- Landlord's willingness to accept assignment
- Strength of your proposed assignee financially
- Whether the landlord will release your personal guaranty
Frequently Asked Questions
- Can the landlord refuse to consent to assignment?
- A lease giving the landlord sole discretion over consent may limit the tenant's options, though how such clauses are enforced varies by jurisdiction. Some leases and jurisdictions limit a landlord's ability to unreasonably withhold consent; consider having an attorney review what remedies, if any, apply.
- What happens to my security deposit when I assign the lease?
- The deposit typically transfers to the assignee. Negotiate the transfer as part of the assignment transaction — you want reimbursement from the assignee for the security deposit you paid.
Know Which Option Is in Your Lease.
LiabilityScore™ reads your actual lease and tells you exactly what provisions you've signed — with specific dollar amounts and negotiation recommendations.
Score My Lease Free